Science fiction is one of the most marketable and profitable genres today. The western used to be one of the most beloved and successful genres ever. Can the two combine to appeal to a modern audience, or do they end up mostly as a mishmash of tonal dissonance and cheese?
2011’s Cowboys and Aliens is about an amnesiac cowboy (Daniel Craig) who wakes up in the middle of the desert. He stumbles upon a former mining town, wherein he immediately find trouble with the son of the town’s sole financier, Colonel Dollarhyde (Harrison Ford). He also meets a strange woman (Olivia Wilde) who seems to know more about him than he does, and she especially seems to know more about the strange shackle on his wrist. After getting arrested, he ends up being one of the people left behind after a group of unknown predators from the sky attack and kidnap half of the town’s population. Will this man discover his past and who he is, as well as save the day?
Directed by Jon Favreau, Cowboys and Aliens is visually impressive but wholly stupid. And honestly? I think that’s a good thing. I wouldn’t have enjoyed this movie nearly as much if the cast hadn’t just gone “Well, we’re in a movie called Cowboys and Aliens. Might as well go hard or go home.” If anyone in the main cast had either phoned it in or played it hokey, it wouldn’t have worked nearly as well for me. That being said, I completely understand the complaint of the movie’s tone being inconsistent with it’s premise. It can be jarring sometimes, especially when meaningful declarations of loyalty and passion are followed up by aliens being shot in explosions of green blood.
That being said, Iron Man alumni Jon Favreau is no amateur when it comes to beautiful shots. I was genuinely impressed with how easy it was to pick important, individual characters out in a wide shot. Whether their hat be a different color from the others, or their horse being a lighter shade of brown, the main characters were always very easy to locate in fight scenes or every time they were shown galloping across the American desert.
The characters are standard fair, but the performances are incredibly dedicated. You’ll probably find that as either clashing with the plot or necessary for enjoying the movie. I was the latter. Daniel Craig stands out as an amoral mercenary who does a better American cowboy accent than Probable-Actual-Cowboy Harrison Ford, who abandons his faux-southern accent for his usual midwestern one three scenes in.
Cowboys and Aliens also does not seek to challenge any preconceptions about what is the status quo for westerns. While the Native American characters are portrayed sympathetically, they are still portrayed as hostile (although with completely good reason). It’s standard popcorn fair, with the biggest message about the old west being “Hey, if the cowboys and Indians were about to be completely wiped out by aliens, all forms of bigotry would be called off in favor of, you know, not dying.”
It’s not for everyone, but if you’re in the mood for something cheesy and light, Cowboys and Aliens might be a decent pick. If you’re a Favreau fan, the DVD release offers an audio commentary with him, along with interviews between him and the cast.
Cowboys and Aliens was an understandable box office flop. I mean, even from the title it’s obvious that it’s not going to be the most mind-blowing movie you’ve ever seen. That being said, I loved this movie. It was dumb and cheesy and I am painfully aware of it’s faults, but I loved it. I completely understand if you would choose to skip it, however. In terms of personal enjoyment, I’d probably give Cowboys and Aliens an A- leaning into a B+, but knowing it’s flaws, I do have to rank it lower.
Grade: C+
11/15/2017